News

Jeremy Corbyn backs permanent customs union after Brexit

Jeremy Corbyn backs permanent customs union after Brexit

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionJeremy Corbyn speaks to the BBC’s Laura Kuenssberg about his Brexit plans

Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn has backed the UK being in a permanent customs union with the EU in a speech setting out his approach to Brexit.

He said this would avoid the need for a “hard border” in Northern Ireland and ensure free-flowing trade for business.

The policy shift could lead to Labour siding with Tory rebels to defeat Theresa May on her Brexit strategy.

The Tories said it was “a cynical attempt” to frustrate Brexit “and play politics with our country’s future”.

Mr Corbyn insisted in an interview with BBC Political Editor Laura Kuenssberg that his speech was a “firming up” of Labour’s existing policy and that he did not want the UK to follow the Norway model, ending up bound by EU rules but having very little say in them.

He said the UK would “have to have a meaningful say” in post-Brexit trade negotiations with the EU “so we would not end up as simply passive rule takers”.

Asked what would happen if the EU said no to his proposal, he said “we would continue talking to them because that’s how you reach agreement”.

He also denied claims by Eurosceptic Labour MPs that he had betrayed Labour voters who had backed Brexit, saying they did not vote “to lose their jobs” and the UK would still be leaving the EU under his plans.

What Corbyn said

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionJeremy Corbyn: Brexit is what we make of it

In his speech, at Coventry University, Mr Corbyn accused the Conservatives of having “no economic plan and no plan for Brexit” and said that under Labour there would be no “scapegoating of migrants, no setting one generation against another and no playing off the nations of the UK”.

He said Labour would be “looking for a Brexit that puts the working people first”.

Labour had already backed customs union membership during the planned two-year transition period after the UK leaves the EU in March 2019. But in a shift from the party’s policy at last year’s general election, he said the UK should strike a new customs deal with the EU at the end of transition.

“Labour would seek a final deal that gives full access to European markets and maintains the benefits of the single market and the customs union… with no new impediments to trade and no reduction in rights, standards and protections,” he said.

“We have long argued that a customs union is a viable option for the final deal. So Labour would seek to negotiate a new comprehensive UK-EU customs union to ensure that there are no tariffs with Europe and to help avoid any need for a hard border in Northern Ireland.”

He added: “Labour respects the result of the referendum and Britain is leaving the EU. But we will not support any Tory deal that would do lasting damage to jobs, rights and living standards.”

How does this differ from the Conservative position?

Image copyright Downing Street
Image caption Theresa May held key Brexit strategy talks at Chequers last week

The prime minister has insisted the UK will leave both the single market and the customs union, allowing it to negotiate its own post-Brexit trade deals.

Mrs May will give details in a speech on Friday of how her plan for a “managed diversion” from the EU will work in practice, after first briefing the cabinet.

The Conservatives accused Mr Corbyn of “betraying millions of Labour voters” who had backed Brexit.

International Trade Secretary Liam Fox said: “Labour’s confused policy would be bad for jobs and wages, it would leave us unable to sign up to comprehensive free trade deals, and it doesn’t respect the result of the referendum.

“This is another broken promise by Labour. Only the Conservatives are getting on with delivering what British people voted for, taking back control of our laws, borders and money.”

Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson accused Mr Corbyn of raising a “white flag” on Brexit in order to try to defeat the government in an upcoming Commons vote on remaining in a customs union.

Mr Johnson tweeted: “Crumbling Corbyn betrays Leave voters – and all because he wants to win a Commons vote. Cynical and deluded.”

What is a customs union?

A customs union allows free-flowing trade between member nations without making companies pay export taxes, or tariffs, at the border. However the members normally have joint trade agreements with countries not in their customs union.

A single market is a deeper form of co-operation, which effectively merges the economies of member states together, allowing the free movement of goods, services, money and people as if they were part of a single country.

Labour and the single market

Image copyright Reuters

Mr Corbyn rejected calls from pro-EU figures like Lord Mandelson and a number of his own backbenchers to commit to staying in the EU single market, saying instead that he wanted a “close relationship” with it.

Shadow Brexit Secretary Sir Keir Starmer has not ruled out continuing with free movement of people between the UK and the EU in some form after Brexit, under Labour’s plans, but he told BBC News it would have to be negotiated – as would any financial contribution the UK would make.

He said the UK could work “jointly” with the EU after Brexit to strike trade deals with other nations – something the government insists is not possible.

Differences not as big as they seem

Analysis By BBC political correspondent Ian Watson

So the dividing lines are clear politically – if less clear in practice. Clear politically, because the government is committed to coming out of the customs union. And in contrast Labour now says it wants to negotiate “a new comprehensive customs union” with the EU.

That puts clear blue water between opposition and government – and may signal to Remain voters that Labour wants a ‘softer’ Brexit, staying closer to the EU. Crucially, it would allow Labour to side with Tory rebels in any forthcoming votes in parliament on the issue – raising the prospect of a government defeat.

But in practice, there may be fewer differences than meets the eye. Jeremy Corbyn wants a customs union that would still give the UK a say in EU-led trade deals – which the EU may resist.

And Theresa May has spoken of a new “customs arrangement,” which would, er, allow independent trade deals. But it’s currently in the government and opposition’s political interests to emphasise the differences, not the similarities.

Could the government fall?

Jeremy Corbyn refused to be drawn on whether his policy shift was an attempt to remove Theresa May from office and force a general election.

Tory rebels have been tight-lipped about whether they would vote against Mrs May if it came down to a confidence vote in her premiership, saying that was unlikely to happen.

Labour’s shadow international trade secretary Barry Gardiner was asked earlier about whether the shift could lead to an election, telling BBC Radio 4’s Today programme: “I don’t know what it would lead to. I don’t think anybody does.”

But Labour MP Frank Field, who backed Leave and said Mr Corbyn was once more Eurosceptic than him, told the BBC that being in a customs union or the single market would be a “deceit” and dismissed suggestions Tory rebels could join with Labour to defeat the government as “fairy tales” and they would win any vote by a large majority.

Jeremy Corbyn used to be a Eurosceptic

Mr Corbyn was an opponent of the EU when he was a backbench Labour MP, as he explained in his speech.

“I have long opposed the embedding of free market orthodoxy and the democratic deficit in the European Union, and that is why I campaigned to ‘remain and reform’ in the referendum campaign.”

He said scepticism was “healthy” but “often the term ‘Eurosceptic’ in reality became synonymous with ‘anti-European’ and I am not anti-European at all, I want to see close and progressive cooperation with the whole of Europe after Brexit”.

He said this “new relationship” he wanted to negotiate with the EU would ensure Labour could deliver on its plans to nationalise public utilities, invest in industry and curb the outsourcing of public services.

He said EU competition rules would, for example, not allow Labour to nationalise the Royal Mail, water and the railways and he would seek exemptions from them and rules restricting state aid of industry.

Reaction to Labour’s policy shift

Mr Corbyn’s speech was welcomed by Britain’s largest trade unions and the industry body the CBI, which said staying in a customs union would “grow trade without accepting freedom of movement or payments to the EU”, although the group said it was sceptical about the Labour leader’s nationalisation plans.

Pro-European Labour MPs said he had not gone far enough, with backbencher Chris Leslie saying: “The only sure and certain way to get the benefits of single market membership is to be a member of the single market and we should not pretend otherwise.”

But former UKIP leader Nigel Farage said it was the “first step in a complete Labour sell-out” and the EU would push Mr Corbyn’s party towards single market membership.

Conservative rebel Stephen Hammond described Mr Corbyn’s speech as “vacuous – he had nothing new to say”. He said he would wait for Mrs May to state her position on customs arrangements after Brexit before deciding whether to vote against her.

The DUP, the party Mrs May relies on to win key votes in the Commons, branded Mr Corbyn’s speech “cheap political opportunism” and assured Mrs May they would “be giving our full support to the government to oppose this Brexit wrecking policy which regardless of the promises made by Corbyn will result in the UK still being tied to regulations, directives and diktats from the EU.”

Liberal Democrats leader Sir Vince Cable tweeted that Mr Corbyn’s customs union stance was a “small step to sanity”, but added: “In #SingleMarket he is still following @theresa-may cake and eat it policy. Just wants red cherries rather than blue raisins.”

You Might Also Like